Showing posts with label civil trial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label civil trial. Show all posts

Monday, May 18, 2015

OPINION Mcculley v US BANK Released for Publication






SYNOPSIS OF THE CASE
2015 MT 100, DA 14-0267: Mary McCulley, Plaintiff and Cross-Appellant v. U.S. Bank , Defendant, Appellant and Cross-Appellee.1

        Mary McCulley bought a condominium in Bozeman and sought a 30-year, residential loan for $300,000 from Heritage Bank, which later merged with U.S. Bank. She later sued the Bank, alleging the Bank defrauded her by instead issuing an 18-month, $300,000 commercial loan, and failing to notify her of the change. When McCulley could not obtain refinancing and the condominium went into foreclosure, she attempted suicide. The jury found that the Bank defrauded McCulley and awarded her $1,000,000 in compensatory damages and $5,000,000 in punitive damages, which the District Court approved.

           On appeal, U.S. Bank argued that testimony it had offered from a former bank officer and McCulley’s medical records were improperly excluded from evidence; challenged the sufficiency of the evidence to support the jury’s finding of fraud; argued that U.S. Bank could not be held liable for punitive damages arising out of Heritage Bank’s conduct that preceded the merger of the banks; and challenged the propriety of the punitive damages award. McCulley cross-appealed the date set by the District Court for interest to begin accruing on the judgment.

         The Montana Supreme Court concluded that, because U.S. Bank had failed to provide the bank officer’s journals to McCulley during the discovery process, the officer was prohibited from testifying with respect to the journals. The Court further concluded that because U.S. Bank failed to lay a proper evidentiary foundation for McCulley’s medical records, they were properly excluded. The Court held that fraud was demonstrated because evidence at trial established that the Bank falsely represented it would provide a 30-year, residential loan to McCulley, the Bank knew the representation was false, and the Bank intended McCulley to rely on the false representation, which she did to her detriment. The Court also held that, because the federal Bank Merger Act required U.S. Bank to assume “all liabilities” of Heritage Bank, U.S. Bank was properly held liable for all damages, including punitive damages, arising out of Heritage Bank’s conduct, and that circumstances proven during the trial supported the punitive damages award because the Bank’s conduct was reprehensible, the ratio between compensatory damages and punitive damages fell within the guidelines provided by the United States Supreme Court, and the statutory cap on punitive damages provided by the Montana Legislature was not exceeded. Lastly, the  Court concluded that interest on the judgment must accrue from the date of the jury’s verdict, not the date of District Court’s post-trial decision approving the award. Thus, the Court affirmed the damages judgment, and reversed the calculation of interest on the judgment.


1 This synopsis has been prepared for the convenience of the reader. It constitutes no part of the Opinion of the Court and may not be cited as precedent.

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Judge signs off on $10 Million fraud suit against WAMU



A California federal judge signed off Monday on a $10 million settlement between units of bankrupt Washington Mutual and class action plaintiffs claiming they were duped into taking out mortgages with low “teaser rates,” after previously denying the deal for an overly broad class definition.

How many others were lured into these predatory loans and had no recourse? Will these plaintiff's
even see a dime after the legal fees are taken out? One can only hope that at least ONE homeowner
who was made homeless by these 'teaser rates' will benefit.

Friday, March 27, 2015

Victim of Mortgage Fraud sent to Prison for winning lawsuit against US BANK.

Mary Mcculley, who won a $6 million dollar lawsuit against US Bank for actual fraud, was labeled a
"danger to society' and sent to a maximum women's penitentiary April 24, 2014. Accused of
 impersonating a government employee, she was forced to take a plea deal with the Montana
DOJ in order to take US Bank to trial.  After proving that the complainants against her were
in fact co- conspirators in the fraud, and providing the government with undisputed proof, she requested to withdraw her plea based on the new evidence.
Senior Judge Sam Haddon ignored Mcculley's request and court appointed counsel was so stunned
they made no effort to argue. Attorney Lenore Albert of Huntington Beach, CA stepped up to the plate and will be arguing Mcculley's appeal on April 6th before the Ninth Court of Appeals.
Mcculley is expected to spend the last few weeks of her year in prison on home confinement.


United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Notice of Docket Activity

The following transaction was entered on 04/06/2015 at 10:16:29 AM PDT and filed on 04/06/2015
Case Name:    USA v. Mary McCulley
Case Number:    14-30099

Docket Text:
SUBMITTED ON THE BRIEFS TO MICHAEL DALY HAWKINS, JOHNNIE B. RAWLINSON and CONSUELO M. CALLAHAN. [9484516] (SB)

Notice will be electronically mailed to:

Ms. Lenore Albert, Attorney
Leif Johnson, Assistant U.S. Attorney
Timothy John Racicot, Assistant U.S. Attorney



Sunday, April 20, 2014

Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Judge upholds $5 Million Punitive Against US BANK, calling behavior 'Abusive"

Judge John Brown of Gallatin County Montana, handed down a stiff order to US BANK this week.
Calling their behavior 'abusive and 'reprehensible in an 22 page brief, the Judge denied US Bank's motion to reduce the punitive damage award to Plaintiff Mary Mcculley. Mcculley filed the lawsuit in 2009, after she was forced to sell her home for $200K less than the appraised value one week prior to foreclosure.  During the litigation, Mcculley claimed US Bank destroyed documents, in addition to the bait and switch she claimed happened at closing.

Although Mcculley applied for a 30-year standard residential loan, she ended up with an 18 month commercial construction loan. Mcculley also accused the lawyers for Defendants of lying to the court and misrepresenting key documents. The jury agreed with her, awarding her $1 million compensatory and $ 5 million in punitive damages after a week long trial in February. US Bank filed motions to reduce the amount of damages, but Montana law states that punitive damages, which are to serve as a deterrent, can be 3% of a company's net worth, or $10 million- which ever is less. Judge Brown explains his decision to uphold the jury's decision:

"This egregious behavior by the Bank constitutes intentional deceit , and supports the conclusion that that the Bank's conduct was reprehensible." Judge brown further cited Seltzer v Morton 2007 MT 62 \stating:

     "Abusive conduct toward and individual which causes the type of harm at issue here
       merits considerable punishment, regardless of the setting in which it takes place.
       However, the fact that [ the Bank] utilized the judicial system as a tool to
      accomplish intimidation and oppression makes this behavior uniquely egregious."

 Mcculley was pro-se until six months before the trial, when Andy Patten and
Patricia Peterman of PPBG, Billings Montana stepped up to the plate. You can read the brief in it's entirety here:
see Judge Brown's order and denial here:http://stopforeclosurefraud.com/2014/04/14/judge-upholds-5-million-punitive-against-us-bank-for-fraud/

http://stopforeclosurefraud.com/2014/04/14/judge-upholds-5-million-punitive-against-us-bank-for-fraud/ Mcculley v American Land Title Company and US BANK MT 2013 89 ( supreme court decision )

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Woman awarded $6M in fraud case against US Bank

Montana March 2014   A woman who sued US Bank alleging the company defrauded her when she sought a $300,000 loan to buy a condo in Bozeman has been awarded $6 million in damages.
    
Gallatin County jury found US BANK guilty of actual fraud and constructive fraud, and on Friday awarded  Mary McCulley $1 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages.
    
McCulley filed suit in June 2009, alleging that US BANK sent her the required 30- year Truth in Lending documents, and instead gave her an 18-month commercial loan. She also claimed the forged deed of trust, which recorded her property as commercial, instead of residential, kept her from being able to refinance with other banks. 
    
McCulley's attorney, Patricia Peterman of Billings, said the verdict was fair.  The lead defense attorney, Mark Sherer / Mackoff Kellogg, for US Bank was not available for comment.

Butte jury's $52 million verdict against bank possibly highest in Montana history




BUTTE — A Butte jury delivered a $52 million verdict Friday against a bank that received billions in federal bailout dollars, but refused to use the money to help a flailing client — an international company that planned to take root in Butte.
The office supply company Masters Group International filed suit against its former bank — Comerica — after the bank reneged on a written forbearance agreement and liquidated the company’s assets while Masters was trying to set up shop in Butte during the recession.
“That act effectively led to the death of the company,” Timothy Strauch, Masters’ attorney told jurors.
Strauch and Mick Taleff — both Missoula-based attorneys — represented Masters during the 10-day trial in Butte district court that resulted in a monetary verdict that Strauch said may be the highest in Montana history.
The suit was initially filed by the Butte Local Development Corp. against Masters, but the business brought the bank in as a third-party defendant. Strauch explained that Masters didn’t have the money it owed the Butte development group because Comerica had breached its contract and taken Masters’ money.
“There are two Americas,” Strauch said in an interview Tuesday. “Comerica — a company in America where the rules don’t apply — and then there’s America, where the rest of us live and the rules do apply.”
In 2006, Comerica offered the start-up company $9.5 million in a revolving line of credit — meaning as long as Masters made its payments, more money could be borrowed.
Strauch argued the bank did so, knowing that Masters was a long way from generating any cash flow. The two-year loan was slated to expire in 2008, and the company borrowed another $1 million from the bank in that time.
Initially, Comerica told Masters it would renew the loan in 2008, but when the recession hit, the bank refused to renew the loan, Strauch said.
When Masters asked for Comerica to use part of its $2.25 billion in federal bailout funds to help it stay afloat, Comerica refused. And Masters was forced to search for an alternative funding source.
“It is not easy . to replace a loan of $10 million or $10.5 million in the middle of a banking crisis,” Strauch said in court.
But the company did find an alternative source, securing a proposal from Wells Fargo to replace Comerica as the operating lender and pay back the $10.5 million borrowed from Comerica. It additionally extended the line of credit to Masters — allowing them an extra $2.5 million “it so desperately had been needing for months to grow and sustain.”
The switch from one lender to the other was slated to occur in February 2009, with the condition that Masters could not be in default with Comerica when Wells Fargo took over. In November 2008, Masters and Comerica signed the forbearance agreement, in which the bank agreed to take no action to collect its loan until February, Strauch said.
But on New Year’s Eve, Comerica took all the money from Masters’ accounts — nearly $9 million — while continuing to charge the company interest, maintenance fees and $82,000 in attorneys’ fees.
“Each time Masters asked the bank for a payoff, it was simply asking how much do we owe you,” Strauch said in his arguments. “Comerica charged it thousands in attorney fees for the simple pleasure of telling Masters how much it owed.”
The result was the destruction of the company — abroad, it shuttered its doors, and it halted any progress in Butte.
After 10 days at trial, the jury spent three hours in deliberation and awarded $41.5 million in compensatory damages and $10.5 million in punitive damages to Masters.
“I think it took a jury in Montana to render this verdict,” Strauch said Tuesday. “Where fair is fair and a deal is a deal.”
In a statement released Tuesday, Comerica CEO Ralph Babb Jr. stated the bank is considering appealing the verdict to the Montana Supreme Court.
Strauch said he is concerned that the bank may appeal the decision. He also expressed frustration that the penalty the company must pay is only a fraction of its entire worth.
“They did something wrong,” Strauch said. “Americans understand that and they are tired of it. This case just exemplifies the division of the haves and the have-nots.”


Read more: http://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/butte-jury-s-million-verdict-against-bank-possibly-highest-in/article_194d857e-9c68-505b-918d-38538f4ca98c.html#ixzz2wRbRv9L1