Showing posts with label Bozeman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bozeman. Show all posts

Monday, May 18, 2015

OPINION Mcculley v US BANK Released for Publication






SYNOPSIS OF THE CASE
2015 MT 100, DA 14-0267: Mary McCulley, Plaintiff and Cross-Appellant v. U.S. Bank , Defendant, Appellant and Cross-Appellee.1

        Mary McCulley bought a condominium in Bozeman and sought a 30-year, residential loan for $300,000 from Heritage Bank, which later merged with U.S. Bank. She later sued the Bank, alleging the Bank defrauded her by instead issuing an 18-month, $300,000 commercial loan, and failing to notify her of the change. When McCulley could not obtain refinancing and the condominium went into foreclosure, she attempted suicide. The jury found that the Bank defrauded McCulley and awarded her $1,000,000 in compensatory damages and $5,000,000 in punitive damages, which the District Court approved.

           On appeal, U.S. Bank argued that testimony it had offered from a former bank officer and McCulley’s medical records were improperly excluded from evidence; challenged the sufficiency of the evidence to support the jury’s finding of fraud; argued that U.S. Bank could not be held liable for punitive damages arising out of Heritage Bank’s conduct that preceded the merger of the banks; and challenged the propriety of the punitive damages award. McCulley cross-appealed the date set by the District Court for interest to begin accruing on the judgment.

         The Montana Supreme Court concluded that, because U.S. Bank had failed to provide the bank officer’s journals to McCulley during the discovery process, the officer was prohibited from testifying with respect to the journals. The Court further concluded that because U.S. Bank failed to lay a proper evidentiary foundation for McCulley’s medical records, they were properly excluded. The Court held that fraud was demonstrated because evidence at trial established that the Bank falsely represented it would provide a 30-year, residential loan to McCulley, the Bank knew the representation was false, and the Bank intended McCulley to rely on the false representation, which she did to her detriment. The Court also held that, because the federal Bank Merger Act required U.S. Bank to assume “all liabilities” of Heritage Bank, U.S. Bank was properly held liable for all damages, including punitive damages, arising out of Heritage Bank’s conduct, and that circumstances proven during the trial supported the punitive damages award because the Bank’s conduct was reprehensible, the ratio between compensatory damages and punitive damages fell within the guidelines provided by the United States Supreme Court, and the statutory cap on punitive damages provided by the Montana Legislature was not exceeded. Lastly, the  Court concluded that interest on the judgment must accrue from the date of the jury’s verdict, not the date of District Court’s post-trial decision approving the award. Thus, the Court affirmed the damages judgment, and reversed the calculation of interest on the judgment.


1 This synopsis has been prepared for the convenience of the reader. It constitutes no part of the Opinion of the Court and may not be cited as precedent.

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Woman awarded $6M in fraud case against US Bank

Montana March 2014   A woman who sued US Bank alleging the company defrauded her when she sought a $300,000 loan to buy a condo in Bozeman has been awarded $6 million in damages.
    
Gallatin County jury found US BANK guilty of actual fraud and constructive fraud, and on Friday awarded  Mary McCulley $1 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages.
    
McCulley filed suit in June 2009, alleging that US BANK sent her the required 30- year Truth in Lending documents, and instead gave her an 18-month commercial loan. She also claimed the forged deed of trust, which recorded her property as commercial, instead of residential, kept her from being able to refinance with other banks. 
    
McCulley's attorney, Patricia Peterman of Billings, said the verdict was fair.  The lead defense attorney, Mark Sherer / Mackoff Kellogg, for US Bank was not available for comment.

The five million dollar punishment

Add caption